I wanted to report in that the "empty" command worked and deleted all the (200,000) comments, but now I have another strange thing going on and would really appreciate your advice. My hostgator account jumped almost double in inodes, which means they won't do backups, so I started clearing out the account and doing manual backups, and when I backed up this particular website (last akeeba backup was done 11/10 (size was 68,375,724) this new one on 12/11 (only change in website was been about 20 k2 blog posts) file size jumped to 566,293,083) I looked in the K2 comments and they have all been deleted-directly from the phpMyAdmin, but something has bloated the size of this site, is there a log file or some history I should also delete-the original problem was 200,000 comments on K2 blog posts. Thanks! Carin